I wrote 2 negative reviews about 2 displays I bought (really terrible and defective), but they weren’t published
Summary: rmservice-it noticed that their negative reviews about two displays they purchased were not published. Other participants, including dady76bay, heavenwelkin, and marioelegio, discussed the issue without providing specific details or solutions in the available content. The discussion focuses on dissatisfaction with the products and the failure to publish the reviews.
Hi everyone, these days I left 2 negative reviews on two displays I got from 2 different suppliers, both of them awful and defective, and even though I submitted the negative reviews for the products, they were not published (only the two positive reviews were left). These reviews seem fake to me.
rmservice-it
16 comments
bre-bre2853
It happened to me too. I had written a negative review about a seller after he sold me an item with a serious defect listed as refurbished, flawless, and in exceptional condition. Ebay removed it at the seller's simple request without giving me the chance to respond. They say it can be edited within 10 days, but instead they removed it after barely 7 days. I wonder: how reliable are reviews on ebay, if negative ones are removed so easily? Is it right to favor a seller who promises the condition of an item that after purchase turns out to be completely false?
marioelegio
If the item you received is not in the condition promised in the listing, you can return it at the seller's expense and you will be fully refunded.
https://www.ebay.it/help/buying/returns-items-not-received-refunds-buyers/restituisci-un-oggetto-cambio-di-un-rimborso?id=4041&st=7&po=2&uci=0&puc=DEFAULT_BUY.BUYER&ri=0
Feedback also has rules; if it was removed, it means you violated those rules.
https://www.ebay.it/help/policies/feedback-policies/regole-sui-feedback?id=4208&st=3&pos=1&query=Regole%20sui%20feedback&intent=regole%20feed&lucenceai=lucenceai&docId=HELP1223
hi
mario
daxsisko
as said earlier in other posts : feedback ( which I remind you is optional...... ) can be left as negative by buyers.... then if according to Ebay it should be removed that is their judgment.... if it stays then it will be up to the seller to decide whether or not to take legal action if it turns out to be defamatory or harmful to their image.....
heavenwelkin
A negative feedback is never 100% reliable; behind it there is anger, resentment, frustration, and maybe the desire to "get even".
Besides the issue of the potentially defamatory comment.
For this reason ebay has put in place rules regarding the posting of negative / neutral feedback.
Best regards
krt3000
much better Amazon
krt3000
ebay is a dictatorial platform, that's all.
cmyk24
I'm starting to understand at this point why there is a certain reluctance to get rid of the many scalpers who infest the site... Negative reviews get deleted, while the scam sellers are better off staying... eBay, eBay, we're really not there at all... You need to take a hard look at your operations!!!!!
dady76bay
I’ll add my experience: I also left a negative review for Grandestore and it disappeared. I just wrote to eBay support to ask for clarification. In my case the seller refused to provide assistance for a product under warranty (a Samsung smartphone I had just bought), which by LAW in Italy must be provided by the seller (the seller then goes to Samsung support for the repair). It seems to me that if a seller does not comply with Italian warranty law, they deserve a negative review... If this is an established practice (the removal of negative reviews), trust in eBay sellers disappears: at this point, for my future purchases I will only consider large retail chains and avoid eBay.
heavenwelkin
The problem is that you have to learn how to use the IT tools made available.
Unfortunately or fortunately (depending on your point of view), over time online sales become increasingly complex and regulated.
A negative feedback that does not meet certain requirements can be removed at the seller's request.
Here you can find something about the feedback rules
https://www.ebay.it/help/policies/feedback-policies/regole-sul-feedback?id=4208
You need to focus on the selling experience and not go after potentially defamatory judgments about the person who sold the item.
For example: if you received an item that did not match the description and the seller hindered the return process and was disrespectful toward you...
you cannot write: arrogant and overbearing seller, I do not recommend this seller (because it would be removed)
You should write, for example: item arrived BROKEN, poor packaging, slow shipping, problems and difficulties encountered during the return process of the item.
Best regards.
dady76bay
Honestly, I had written a completely harmless review, with no insults at all, stating only the facts: no defamation, just the plain and simple truth.
Here it is:
Nonexistent after-sales support. I set up the smartphone, transferred all the data and it worked. I connected it to the notebook via the official Samsung Smart Switch software and did an update: the screen turned blue and the phone no longer shows any signs of life. Contacted the seller: he insinuated that I had caused the problem myself (how?) and told me to contact Samsung support. I had proposed a return (they could send it in for service themselves) and sending a replacement product.
It is therefore true that eBay support itself replied to my request for clarification regarding the removal of the feedback in this way:
"[...]Please keep in mind that an item that stops working after you have used it and connected it to the notebook via the official Samsung Smart Switch software, falls under the Product Warranty but not under the eBay Customer Guarantee, which does not represent a guarantee on a product or service, but is an additional commercial service and does not replace any legal warranty provided for by consumer protection or civil law.
Consumers can exercise their rights against the seller under the legal warranty of conformity of the product.
The legal warranty on consumer goods is specifically provided for and regulated by the Consumer Code, to protect the consumer in the event of purchasing defective products or products that do not correspond to the use declared by the seller or to which that good is generally intended.
The aforementioned legislation provides that the consumer may assert their rights regarding the legal warranty of conformity, by contacting the seller of the item directly, even if this is different from the manufacturer."
In practice, they confirm that the warranty must be provided by the seller, but for them that is not a sufficient reason to assign negative feedback.
marioelegio
Regarding your feedback:
Non-existent after-sales support is the problem, you drew this conclusion (your subjective one) from your objective experience. Under Italian law, this statement violates criminal code art. 595 c2, as it is a subjective statement that harms the honor of the person receiving this feedback.
You will never have any way to prove that in all cases there will be non-existent after-sales support, just based on your experience of a single case.
You cannot draw a general conclusion from your one experience of a particular case.
This sentence alone is enough for immediate removal of the feedback. If it did not, ebay would make itself complicit in a crime.
bye
mario
dady76bay
AHAHAHAHA!
You guys who defend the indefensible really make me laugh!
By definition, every review reports one’s own subjective experience! If I leave a review of a restaurant saying I ate terribly, it’s obvious I’m referring to my own experience (and what I ate) and not in general.
If it were like you say, reviews could no longer be posted because ALL of them are based on a subjective experience.
Besides, eBay support completely contradicts you, since after my repeated insistence about what the problem with the removed review was, they replied:
"I inform you that feedback should be left for anything related to the transaction. For example, feedback can be left for long delivery times, a package never shipped, a package arrived broken, defective items, item returns, etc., but not for something that is not covered by the eBay customer guarantee.
That is, eBay offers the right to a refund within 30 days for an item not received, or if the item arrived defective, or if it turned out to be defective during first use, but it does not offer a 1- or 2-year warranty; this is provided by the seller or by the manufacturer. So since the feedback was left for something not covered by the eBay customer guarantee, while the transaction went very well with no problems, the feedback was removed and cannot be restored anymore."
Got it? The problem is that they don’t give a damn if a seller doesn’t comply with Italian warranty law!
daxsisko
everyone can make their own assessment on feedback :
the buyer CAN decide whether to leave a negative one or not......
Ebay, upon the seller's appeal, CAN decide whether to remove it or not......
the seller CAN decide, if the feedback appears defamatory to them, to file a complaint within the terms of the law...... so in some cases, for the buyer, in the end it is a good thing that eBay removes a negative feedback ......
heavenwelkin
Things should be explained with much more attention to detail....
If you didn't receive satisfactory answers, it's very likely that you didn't provide enough details to get a targeted answer.
Ebay provides assistance up to 30 days after receiving the item.
If you tried to ask ebay for assistance after the thirtieth day and before the sixtieth day, posting a negative containing the following phrase: "the seller does not provide assistance"......
On ebay the seller cannot provide a 24-month warranty or provide assistance on ebay after the 30 days are up; you have to use other methods, other approaches, and other channels.
What did you buy?
A smartphone? brand? Italian, European, or international warranty?
Did you receive the invoice from the professional seller?
Did you contact the seller, making what kind of request and/or claim?
Did you do it mentioning ebay, paypal, or making some other kind of request.
What did you ask the seller? Did they reply to you? If so, what did they say?
Making a mess of it like this isn't useful to anyone.
Best regards.
marioelegio
If your negative review disappeared while others remain where they are, clearly you're the one who hasn't understood the difference between a subjective opinion and an objective description of what happened.
bye
mario
heavenwelkin
The feedback as you left it is NOT OK for the reason that marioelegio explained to you.
Did you by any chance open a dispute with eBay for item not as described?
What outcome did you have with the dispute?
Kind regards.