The buyer is always right! (a much-debated topic over and over again!)
Summary: The thread discusses the statement "The customer is always right!" with various participants sharing their opinions on this often-debated topic. Several people, including ciappelloni87, marioelegio, and heavenwelkin, take part in the discussion, although the specific details of their contributions are not provided.
More than a question, mine is a small rant, or at most a rhetorical question open to a civil discussion, if that were even possible.
I’m not a professional seller, but over the years I’ve still built up my respectable and costly history on ebay with over 500 100% positive feedback ratings, and a good chunk of those, especially lately, are as a seller with customers who are extremely satisfied and almost surprised by the level of service and attention they received (a hobby seller, basically always consistently at a loss, modestly enough... but I do something else for a living! ) .
Well, at the end of September a person (with zero feedback, who if I could, without knowing how to read or write, I’d happily block) bought a smartphone from me, and after a couple of days claimed that the package arrived empty. He takes a photo and a video of the package, which by any logic have zero value, absolutely none, just as an eventual video made by me while packing the parcel would be worth zero. If I were a scammer, nothing would stop me from then shipping another empty one and not the one shown in the video. As proof it is worth less than zero.
Well, it really seems that Ebay decided to protect the buyer, zero feedback, no history on ebay. But not to protect him at his own expense, which would also make sense. Fair enough, you want to show buyers that ebay protects them, and you invest your own money in this thing, making them feel safe on your platform... fair enough!
No, ebay wants to protect him at my expense... moreover without EVER consulting me throughout the entire dispute, having consulted ONLY and EXCLUSIVELY the buyer. In practice, the buyer decides what happened.
I therefore gather that selling on ebay is a huge risk, if the word of a buyer with zero feedback is enough to make you lose 700 euros despite your sales history and the sums you’ve made ebay earn in seller fees. And what if the next customer also says that an empty package arrived? What am I supposed to do, hand out money and smartphones left and right, do charity???
To this is added a very nice new development, just to complete the picture. It seems that for Poste Italiane it has become illegal, for retail customers, to ship smartphones. So for years I’ve been throwing 16.90 euros of insured express shipping down the drain every time I pay to send them.
Then again, in the rules they linked me to from Poste, they talk about lithium batteries and never explicitly about smartphones, so one would also have to be an expert in the internal components of smartphones.
Years ago I received a couple of reimbursements for lost smartphones, reduced by 10% of the invoice value... today it has become illegal, but only when they have to reimburse you, because nobody tells you in plain words that a SMARTPHONE cannot be shipped! They let you ship it just fine, but if it gets lost, it becomes illegal!
I really ended up in a crappy situation, one I honestly would never have imagined... ebay or paypal (I’m not sure whose smart idea it is) showing off their buyer protection, but at the seller’s expense...
And the postal service that considers shipping smartphones illegal on a par with weapons and drugs! (they are in the same list as lithium batteries, this is not a joke) .
October started off really badly... but it can always get worse!
nimess1
I'm going through the same experience as you right now, and I don't think it'll end well, even with over 1500 positive feedback and expressions of appreciation from customers. I can't believe there are people who want to screw someone over for a few euros. They're desperate for cash.
ciappelloni87
OPSorry, I forgot a small note about when Paypal steps in, at least in my limited experience.
In the past, Paypal has reimbursed a couple of buyers who had given me insanely troublesome problems based on nothing, with no demonstrable proof, just like in this case, but for smaller amounts — if I remember correctly, we're talking about 150 euros — but it had refunded the customers out of its own pocket, stepping in almost like a sort of insurance for the customer.
Ebay, on the other hand, takes the money out of your pocket and hands it to someone else... there's a huge difference!
heavenwelkin
It seems to me that you are very caught up and set on going your own way.....so I invite you to reread this discussion maybe in a couple of weeks.
Paypal deals with payments and it is NORMAL that it is optimized to handle payment disputes in a more serious and accurate way than ebay.
Ebay could also have a more accurate and resource-intensive dispute management system, but the fact remains that if the buyer doesn’t like Ebay’s verdict, they open a Paypal dispute, and if they don’t like Paypal’s verdict either, they can try to open a dispute (chargeback) with their bank.
So you have to start from the assumption that if a buyer opens a dispute on ebay, they are almost always protected.
If you don’t want to risk major financial losses or giving away more items, I recommend setting a maximum price cap and considering excluding from sale all those fashionable / trendy / highly sought-after items that are easy to resell even outside the internet.
Kind regards
ciappelloni87
OPThanks for the advice.
Already knowing a dynamic helps you prevent it or better yet ( or worse... ) exploit it, since in a certain way you have to adapt to the rules of the environment you live in.
Unfortunately I didn’t know how easy it was to scam a seller on ebay or, in any case, to get people to side with you when there’s a total absence of evidence.
Now I know, and I’ll act accordingly, for better or worse, but respecting the " rules " .
Thanks and have a great weekend.
ciappelloni87
OP" The buyer provided law enforcement documentation stating that the box received was empty. "
This statement is incredible, it hardly needs any explanation.
The buyer simply went to law enforcement to say that the box was empty, and law enforcement wrote it down on a sheet of paper.
So all you have to do is buy a smartphone, say the box was empty, go report it to the police too, and Ebay AUTOMATICALLY sides with the buyer, but not at its own expense, rather with the seller's money 😠😠😠😠😠
heavenwelkin
Distance sales are anything but safe if you sell certain types of items.
Any chargebacks from the Visa/Mastercard network or PayPal disputes are not under eBay's control, which in this case ends up being an intermediary.
For this reason too, dispute handling in most cases goes in favor of the buyer.
There is no point getting angry; now that you’ve realized how easy it is to get scammed, you will certainly set a maximum limit for how much money and how much of the item you’re willing to lose, and you will certainly avoid selling certain types of items.
Best regards.
ciappelloni87
OPThank you for your contribution.
Actually, I considered myself fully protected by the insured express shipping that in the past had always, in fact, protected me from this kind of murky situation.
On this occasion there was a whole series of coincidences that screwed me over (for the moment... meanwhile today I filed a report with the Police after managing to get the phone's IMEI from Xiaomi, something that took quite a bit of effort and may come in handy), namely eBay, which without the slightest proof from the buyer, automatically sides with him (I couldn't have known), the Post Office, which suddenly considers the smartphone (even though they don't clearly write it anywhere, and for that I have already gone to a lawyer, he will advise me whether and what to do) a forbidden item to ship, but only for private individuals and only if it is lost or stolen, because otherwise no one clearly tells you that a smartphone cannot be shipped.
And then the funny part, so to speak, is that in any case eBay, when refunding the buyer, kept the entire amount of the sale from me, thus holding back 35 euros in selling fees. The damage and the insult.
I wanted to point out a small detail regarding the total lack of evidence produced by the buyer.
Amazon, which always and in any case sides with its customers in an outrageous way (I say that as a plus, I am a very loyal customer), returns, refunds, refunds without returning the goods and so on, which truly prostrates itself before the customer even when they are dead wrong, only one single time did not want to hear reason and ruled against me, making me lose about 7 euros (not the almost 700 of eBay!), and that was when a package arrived to me empty, when it should have contained a cover for a smartphone.
The delivery guy, in fact, when handing me the cardboard envelope, told me it seemed completely empty, although perfectly sealed.
I accept the package, I call Amazon support, I open the envelope live on the phone with them and despite, I repeat, Amazon prostituting itself for its customers, in the end they told me it was IMPOSSIBLE to prove that the package was actually empty, even though I opened it live on the phone, after asking for permission to open it!
There is no way to prove that you received an empty package, maybe only a video made BEFORE opening the package, but even in that case there would be many things to object to. How do you prove you hadn't already opened it and resealed it?
Instead eBay claims to have proof that the package arrived empty, and among this evidence the deposition report released to the Police stands out, that is, a simple statement by the buyer. Zero value.
On eBay the buyer is always right, even when they can't prove it in any way.
This is.....
ciappelloni87
OPHere’s the email that was just sent to me:
" After reviewing the dispute, we decided to issue a full refund in favor of the buyer.
The buyer provided law enforcement documentation stating that the box received was empty.
A refund of EUR 639.00 was issued on Oct. 16, 2025 in favor of the buyer. The refund covers the purchase price and the original shipping costs.
eBay will recover the refunded amount from you. "
ciappelloni87
OPSmall addition about something that left me very puzzled about who then gets tasked with making these decisions, which are important all the same.
A person from eBay told me on the phone that the key proof was that the Police had also written a report stating that the package had arrived empty. He told me verbatim: "the Police wrote it too!".
But the Police simply recorded a statement from the buyer.... you can say whatever you want, they just write it down and that’s that. It’s not like the Police affirm and sign off on what you dictate to them in the report. The Police didn’t say a damn thing.
When I heard those words I didn’t feel in very good hands.......
ciappelloni87
OPI thank you for the replies.
I can also understand this dynamic; I myself am much more of a buyer than a seller ( I’d say 98/2 ) , so I would feel protected and at ease when buying.
What I don’t understand, though, is how eBay can step into the role of a judge ( probably there’s something in the various contractual loopholes we all agree to when we sign ) and decide who to block the money from, who to take it away from, and who to give it to.
What I mean is that if someone goes to a judge in court, it’s obviously fair that the judge can order me to pay something because they believe I’m in the wrong and the other party is in the right ( without getting into the specifics of my case ) .
But eBay is not a judge... buyer protection could also be a very honorable and extremely understandable project, but only if the platform took on the burden of such a project, and not by taking money from one person and giving it to another arbitrarily, especially where there is, as in my case, a total lack of evidence. In fact, at least from my shipping receipt I can prove the weight of the package when it left. The person who received the package, once it was opened, I don’t know what they can prove.
This power in Italy, I believe, though maybe I’m wrong and you never stop learning, is something only judges in court have. eBay is in effect replacing a court.
And if there is no evidence, it still makes clear-cut decisions, not 50 and 50, so to speak.
Some people make the deal of a lifetime and others come out battered and bruised.
heavenwelkin
Sooner or later every seller realizes that selling remotely is equivalent to having a certain percentage of risk on the item sold, which in some cases can reach 30%.
In a situation like this, you clearly understand that if I have to sell, for example, a used MacBook for 2000 euros with electronic payment and shipping, I may need to stop for a moment and think about whether it would be better to sell it with in-person pickup and cash payment.
I’ll definitely make less than if I do it through eBay (that’s for sure), but at least I won’t run the risk of some shipping employee taking possession of the contents of the package or a buyer trying to scam me.
Once you’ve become aware of the problem, you have to try to avoid putting up for sale items that are particularly in demand and easy to resell, because the risk of running into a scammer is very high.
If you sell vintage items, you can rest fairly easy that you certainly won’t see scams this blatant.
You may run into a picky, fussy buyer who might latch onto some detail to try to knock a few euros off....... but no more than that.
Sorry for the inconvenience.
Best regards
marioelegio
Unfortunately, this is part of the implicit risk in all distance sales, on any platform.
If the item is paid for with PayPal, Klarna,... or by credit card, where the platform is not involved, the payment method protection comes into play.
In doubtful cases, where there is no evidence for or against, everyone sides with the buyer.
hi
mario