Non-original item: return or report to the Financial Police?
Hello, I received a replacement display for a smartphone sold as original, but I was sent a compatible one that is absolutely not original and works badly too, it even differs from the photos the seller uploaded in the listing (where it is certainly original).
The problem is that, since I urgently needed it, after testing that it turned on I glued it to the smartphone and now I would have to pry it off to return it, with all the risks that entails (cracks, breakage).
Speaking with eBay on the phone I asked whether I could protect myself by reporting it to the Guardia di Finanza, which would obviously have seized the replacement part, and to my surprise the operator said that in that case
I definitely would not have gotten any refund because, original or not, it has to be returned.
eBay also initially "did me over" when, in a previous call, it asked me to request the return, and then to ask them again to step in so I could get the refund; instead today, when I got the return label, the operator told me something completely different.
PayPal, on the other hand, suggested I open a dispute for a damaged item, which is not really relevant to the case.
What could I do?
I contacted the seller the day after receiving the item, but he didn’t really seem willing to help me and denied that it wasn’t original, saying that different configurations can exist. Now I fear that once he receives the return he will deny the refund because in the listing he specified that the refund is denied in case of a used/installed item. I sent the photographic and video evidence both to him and to eBay
heavenwelkin
You should have written on the forum before installing the replacement part; in that case we would have been able to help you.
As a DIY hobbyist, you were not able to tell whether the replacement part was original or not simply by inspecting it, and you had to install it anyway.
Once you have fitted the replacement part, it is NO LONGER IN ITS ORIGINAL CONDITION, so you cannot ask for a refund.
Now the only thing left for you to do is keep this display or buy a new one.
Kind regards.
undi-bay
OPAnyway, thanks for replying. Normally I’d absolutely agree with you and I wouldn’t even have posted here, nothing to say.
But I’m not talking about something blatantly different, like “are you crazy, how could you not notice?”. Visually at first glance it looks original; you only realize something’s off when you actually use it. The usual display tests built into Android phones themselves don’t go into that much depth (those are the tests I’d run before installing it); I had to dig deeper myself with third-party apps after noticing something wasn’t right. The physical and visual difference is only on the microcomponents (MICRO) on the back, which on my broken original were covered by black stickers, so I didn’t even think to compare them (and yes, mea culpa) and which instead match the ones shown in the listing photos.
By playing on that, who knows how many he sold to “hobbyists” like me who just kept it like that and shrugged it off; I don’t think it’s right that he keeps passing them off as original. Besides, people also tend to trust mostly positive feedback, otherwise what’s the point.
At first I even thought it was just a defect and I offered the seller at most a partial refund, realizing by then that I had already installed it, but he didn’t accept.
I wonder what the point of eBay’s warranty is if you have to invent Ferrari engineers to test and verify a product.
That said, thanks anyway for your opinion,
Best regards to you too
heavenwelkin
Dear undi-bay
That said, counterfeiting / cloning / reproduction of items is extremely widespread and affects every product sector.
What should a seller do who, in good faith, buys a batch of original items that are not actually original?
Take everything to the Guardia di Finanza and have the shipment seized, and then go and report the Chinese supplier?
I too was recently a “victim” of a counterfeit item (a pair of smartphone headphones); I realized they weren’t original and opened a dispute for an item not matching the description.
In your specific case, the only workable solution is to take the smartphone to a repair center and make it clear that you want the original display and not a clone.
In that case, if the repairer installs a non-original display, you can go after them directly.
Sorry for the inconvenience.
Kind regards.