Report negative feedback
Hello everyone,
I would like to ask whether it is possible to report negative feedback that I consider unfair.
Basically, I sold some comic books for €25, and the first one is quite sought after.
I packaged them well as the buyer requested.
I am more than sure they were in excellent condition when I sold them; they are still used items, since they come from my collection, and obviously there are slight signs of reading, but for me, as collectibles, they were very good.
Last week the seller writes to me saying that in his opinion they are very damaged, not because of the shipping... he sends me some broken links where he made the videos.
On top of that he accuses me of dishonesty, something that, as my feedback can attest since 2015, is not part of who I am.
The accusation comes from the fact that even though I am always careful that the photos I post are clearly visible, and I also remember editing them, eBay probably did not save the edit, they were low quality.
But the flaws could still be seen... then he didn’t even ask for more photos, which I would have gladly taken.
I got angry at that moment because of the accusation and, on top of that, he was very rude, making excuses that part of the spine could not be seen (we’re talking about barely a millimeter...).
I ask him to send me photos in chat and even then he makes excuses... so I propose making a full return, instead of the partial one he suggested.
He replies that I don’t have a clear idea... at which point, I probably made a mistake by blocking him in a fit of anger.
But I’ve been on eBay since 2015, as I said, and being accused of dishonesty when I do everything I can, in my small way, to show transparency and often, in fact, it is recognized, for a small oversight I get assigned negative feedback where I am accused again of dishonesty... so I would like to understand whether it is possible to report it or how to make sure the average doesn’t drop too much.
Thank you to anyone who replies.
heavenwelkin
Good afternoon lunacomics17
Looking at the auction photos, they seem to me to be in excellent condition.
Writing "Perfect condition and then "Suitable for demanding collectors" puts you at a disadvantage because then the shrewd collector comes along and seizes the opportunity, looking for any little flaw to try to get something knocked off the price paid.
In my opinion it wasn't a manic collector but someone who was simply trying it on and then in the discussion everyone got carried away and things started to deteriorate....
So without getting into disputes and arguments where everyone claims to be right, I would have written to the buyer that I was willing to take the items back and that I would provide the return label at my own expense, I would have invited the buyer to open a dispute for item not as described so that in the event of a possible rethink on his part and expiry / closure of the dispute I would also have been protected from any negative feedback since the buyer did not complete the return procedure.
Regarding the negative feedback, follow the advice that marioelegio gave you, insisting on the fact that in the feedback there are personal considerations which, although not defamatory, should not be there, as per eBay rules.
Good luck.
Kind regards.
lunacomics17
OPFirst of all, thank you for the advice.
Yes, I think so too.
I had theorized that since the series consists of 3 volumes, she might have replaced them with my own damaged volumes, taking advantage of the photos.
In fact, I’ll remove that wording because I think it only invites trouble.
Even if what I have left is mostly comics that were already second-hand.
sika700
The feedback is formally correct, so it’s unlikely to be removed... but trying to ask support about it costs nothing.
This experience teaches you that for online sales you need a lot of patience and to keep your nerves under control.
What would I have done?
Without beating around the bush and without wasting time, I would have sent him a full return label... so as to pass the ball to the buyer and see whether he was actually just trying to get a partial refund or whether he actually wanted to return them.
They say you learn from your mistakes.
Kind regards.
marioelegio
…….. you insist on the definition of inflexible seller, since (although not offensive) it is a subjective judgment from the buyer (and as such violates eBay rules).
hi
mario
lunacomics17
OPThanks Mario!
I sent the report to eBay; unfortunately, I didn’t realize there was a form I could fill out.
Is there a way to add details? Or will eBay contact me?
Also, I noticed something strange about this user, maybe it can happen, but anyway they entered a cellphone number with all the same digits.
At first I thought that since sometimes they contact you about things unrelated to the sale, they had done it as a precaution.
But anyway, for eBay isn’t it against the rules to enter a fake number? If it actually is
lunacomics17
OPAnd I’m telling you, you’re awesome! I really hadn’t thought of that!
I really like this solution a lot!
I try to keep my cool, but unfortunately with certain people, especially in this field, it’s difficult... clearly not everyone is like that, but some collectors get to maniacal levels and if the item doesn’t meet their impossible demands they drive you crazy...