Appeal against an unjustified Ebay/Paypal decision in favor of the seller
Good morning,
I bought a collectible coin, based on the listing photos, described as "magnificent," in top condition.
The coin I received was absolutely not in such condition; it had been heavily cleaned, and I noticed that the listing photos had been manipulated to hide these defects.
I asked the seller for a return, but he did not accept it: I appealed to PayPal and, SURPRISINGLY (despite the photos and the evidence sent), they rejected my claim.
To top it all off, they removed the negative feedback left for the seller.
Of course I am also willing to pursue legal action, but I cannot accept sic et simpliciter this unfortunate decision.
I thank everyone who has suffered a similar injustice and can advise me on the best way to protect my rights as a buyer.
sika700
MentoreGood morning,
if the seller rejected your return request, it’s because you must have stated the reason incorrectly without a doubt... the seller can refuse a change of mind only, while they are obliged to accept non-conformity... and the fact that PayPal came to the same conclusion confirms it.
So, most likely, you made a mistake when submitting the request.
Or else, the collectible currency did not comply with eBay’s rules, and so you could not take advantage of eBay’s buyer guarantee.
Rules on collectible currencies | eBay
Best regards.
claire772016
OPNo, the seller (French) did not acknowledge the non-conformity and PayPal said it would only have accepted it if it had not been the same coin. In practice, it assessed it as a subjective evaluation of the same item. Since they did not have expertise on the subject, they did not identify the photo manipulation
marioelegio
MentoreMaybe the first mistake was not asking for the return through eBay; probably eBay's procedure (for item not as described) would have allowed you to return it. https://www.ebay.it/help/buying/returns-items-not-received-refunds-buyers/restituisci-un-oggetto-cambio-di-un-rimborso?id=4041&st=7&po=2&uci=0&ri=0
In these cases it's always advisable to use eBay procedures first (return request and any appeal) and then PayPal only as a last resort.
hi
mario