Unjustly closed controversy
Summary: crazysaint83 opened a discussion titled 'Unjustly closed controversy' but did not provide any content in their original post. marioelegio replied, but that contribution also contained no content.
Hello, I'm Vincenzo. On January 30 I sold an Australian my collector's edition of the game "Dragon Quest III HD 2d remake ps5". In the listing and more precisely in the item description, it said in capital letters "NO DLC EXCLUSIVE SQUARE ENIX STORE", but that did not stop the madness of the crazy Australian, who started demanding the DLC, wanted screenshots of my purchases on Square and on PSN, and when I got tired and didn't answer him for 2 days, he opened a dispute claiming that the game had not arrived as described and evidently the people at eBay must have misunderstood, thinking that I had sent him nothing, since their page for tracking the shipment was not updating and the package always showed as in transit, when in fact I promptly called Italian Post, who assured me that the game had arrived at its destination. I also checked on Australian Post and parcel tracking and they all showed the package delivered, and even the buyer made it clear to me that he was in possession of the game. I immediately called eBay, who told me I should wait 3 working days to request their intervention. On Thursday, February 13, 2025, I didn't get the chance to call them and in the evening I found the message "dispute opened". The next day I called eBay again explaining the whole situation, but either they didn't understand or they pretended not to. I explained very clearly that the buyer received everything except the DLC described in my listing as "MISSING". They simply told me they would contact eBay Australia and that they in turn would have to send me an email. No email received and today the message: "Dispute closed in favor of the buyer, issue refund"... I contacted the buyer and told him I would issue the refund if he sent the game back to me... he never replied again. Basically, I lose the many hundreds of euros the game is worth + the refund money, coming to about €1000, while the buyer would end up with the collector's game + many other refunded euros. I received this treatment from eBay even though I've been a buyer for 16 years with all positive feedback and for 3-4 years also a seller, and even in this case all positive feedback; I have always satisfied every buyer. I don't think anyone has ever had my experience because this is real bad luck. A buyer going crazy over a nonexistent DLC and eBay that didn't listen to me or try to get us to reach an agreement. Now, I repeat, the Australian, by not replying, has no intention of returning the game while my account will be debited by €520. If anyone has any advice to give me, I would be truly grateful; this situation has enormously ruined me.
marioelegio
MentoreWas the dispute for item not received or for item not as described?
You can try appealing eBay’s decision, but it would only make sense if the dispute was for item not received. You could provide proof of actual delivery with the courier’s documentation.
If instead the dispute is for item not as described, you made a serious procedural mistake and it’s practically impossible to fix. You should have sent the return label within the three business days that eBay gave you to get your game back. Now you can file a complaint for misappropriation, but I think that won’t worry the Australian.
hi
mario