Two feedbacks from a SINGLE transaction: eBay error or tolerated scam?
Summary: The discussion is about an issue with eBay, where the author vendo-franco asks whether receiving two feedback entries from a single transaction is an eBay error or an accepted form of deception. marioelegio and sika700 take part in the conversation, trying to clarify the situation and offer their opinions on the issue.
Hello everyone,
I am a professional seller with years of experience on eBay.
I’m reporting a very serious incident that happened to me:
A buyer made just one transaction (one, single one), but managed to leave two separate feedback entries for that one purchase (both negative).
Order no. 06-13346-40983 – item ID 324854289609.
Result: 2 feedbacks published, as if he had bought twice.
I reported the problem to support, but the response was surreal:
“It’s a personal opinion, it doesn’t violate the rules.”
But here we’re not talking about opinions: eBay’s system allows ONLY ONE feedback for each transaction. This is a bug, or an abuse not handled by support.
I’m reaching out to anyone who has experienced similar situations: has a “double feedback” ever happened to you on a single sale? What did you do? Is there a way to get justice from eBay, or do we have to resign ourselves?
If this is seller protection, then we’re all exposed to serious reputation damage without any protection.
I look forward to any opinions, experiences, or suggestions on how to move forward.
Thanks for the support.
sika700
MentoreHello,
since this is a listing with variations, if the buyer purchased two items from you, they count as two transactions, so two feedbacks.
Kind regards.
vendo-franco
OPThanks to you too for the reply.
I understand the technical logic behind the listing with variants, but the fact remains that the purchase was made in a single transaction, with a single payment, and above all a single shipment (one label, one package).
So as a seller I end up with: with two publicly visible negative feedbacks, which look like two different experiences; whereas if it had been a positive feedback, there would have been only one, not two.
This imbalance is obvious: in the case of negative feedback, two are shown, but in the case of positive feedback, no.
It seems clear to me that this is a disparity that penalizes the seller.
In addition, I point out that: when I sell multiple items in the same transaction, even with variants, only one feedback is counted in the score; but visually both negative comments remain.
So it’s not just a “score” issue, but an image and perception issue for future buyers who, reading two identical, closely spaced negative feedbacks, might think there were two separate problems.
I believe this dynamic deserves a review from eBay.
Best regards,
Franco
sika700
MentoreBut there are still two items... and therefore two transactions... and consequently two feedbacks.
If you notice, even though you received two ratings, for the percentage eBay calculated only one, as actually happens for positive ones.
So it's just your feeling... but everything is correct.
Have a good evening.
marioelegio
MentoreIf you click the i next to your feedback percentage, you'll see that the two feedback entries have been considered as one only.
hi
mario
vendo-franco
OPThanks Mario for the reply,
I checked and confirm that from a technical standpoint eBay considers the two feedbacks as one only in the percentage calculation.
However, the problem remains: visually, anyone who looks at my feedback profile sees TWO distinct negative feedbacks, both left by the same buyer and for a single transaction.
This creates an objective image damage, because a visitor can easily think that I received two separate negative experiences, when instead it is one sale and one person only.
On top of that, there is also a disparity in treatment:
When the opposite happens — that is, I sell multiple items to the same buyer in a single transaction — the buyer can leave many positive feedbacks, but only one is counted.
Here, instead, the opposite happens: two visible negative feedbacks for a single transaction, and no way for the seller to offset the visual impact.
So I’m wondering:
Is it normal that two negative feedbacks can be left for a single purchase?
Isn’t this a flaw that unfairly penalizes sellers?
If a buyer can leave two separate negative judgments for a single sale, then the system loses all consistency.