Can buyers really keep scamming so easily?
Good morning everyone, I’m writing because something is happening that in my opinion is extremely serious, and it could open the door to all eBay scammers at the expense of honest sellers. I’ll keep it brief: about 2 months ago a user bought an item worth €620 from my eBay store, to be precise a gas boiler; after more than 45 days, so well after the 14 days provided by law to make a return, having realized that he had caused major damage to the boiler, he decided to open a dispute through PayPal, since eBay no longer allowed it (rightly so) and, believe it or not, PAYPAL through eBay fully refunded the buyer, allowing him to send me back an item that is now fit only for scrap. After contacting eBay’s EU phone support, the operator immediately brushed me off saying that any appeal will be rejected, so I will have to consider the case already closed in favor of the scammer. Are we kidding? Is it really possible for scams to be this easy? Is it possible that eBay can’t find a solution to this?
marioelegio
MentoreYou yourself said that the decision was made by PayPal, what can eBay tell you?
These are common problems with all transactions made remotely and paid for with credit cards, PayPal and other similar systems.
hi
mario
idrotermosanitari
OPHi Mario, thank you very much for the kind feedback. Yes, the product warranty is 24 months, but there is no proof that the customer called the official technician to ask for a free on-site intervention; on the contrary, more than once via eBay messaging we invited the buyer to contact support and, if necessary, send us a written statement (stamped and signed by the authorized technician) confirming a malfunction or damage caused not by the buyer. Obviously, the buyer never replied to our invitation and, as usual, even in the absence of proof, the buyer always prevails over the seller because of a law that we believe is unfair. As for PayPal, it is true that the decision was theirs, but the transaction took place on eBay, shouldn’t we sellers be “protected” from these scams?
Thanks
marioelegio
MentoreI had emphasized that in the first 6 months it is the seller who must prove that it is not a conformity defect, precisely because the EU directive protecting consumers provides that they only have to inform the seller of the presence of the defect.
Also in the first 6 months, it is not up to him to contact support and prove the defect (possibly, send us a written statement (stamped and signed by the authorized technician) confirming a malfunction or damage caused not by the buyer), the law places this burden on the seller.
The law has been in force in Italy since 2006 and does not allow exceptions; in fact, contractual clauses or commercial practices that tend to reduce its effectiveness can be sanctioned by the Competition and Market Authority.
As for PayPal, if PayPal (without any eBay judgment) asks eBay to return the amount, it is then obvious that eBay will go after the seller.
Seller protection is valid only in the case where, after an eBay judgment in favor of the seller, there is a contrary decision from PayPal or the credit card. In these cases eBay keeps its first decision valid and bears the cost of the dispute.
bye
mario