If the buyer changes their mind
Good morning,
I’m writing about a problem that leaves me puzzled.
On 1/13 the buyer purchased an item for sale, but unfortunately I didn’t receive any notification and only noticed it on 1/21 during my lunch break by pure chance. I let the buyer know that I would ship on Monday and apologized for the delay.
On the morning of 1/22 I shipped the package via eBay shipping with the label provided
On the morning of 1/26 I received a request for item not received, and I told them that the package had been shipped on Monday, so it was normal for it to be late (the tracking code is there); however, the buyer told me the item was no longer needed and that they preferred a refund.
The listing clearly states that returns are not accepted, however since in the end I am also partly responsible for the delay, I agree to refund them, I try to contact the post office but they tell me I cannot cancel the shipment and it must first be delivered and then reversed.
I therefore inform the buyer that as soon as they receive the package, they will have to send it back to me (at their own expense, since according to the rules it states that if the return is due to a change of mind by the buyer, they must bear the shipping cost).
Here the real drama begins: they reply with “absolutely not,” leave me negative feedback calling me dishonest, and open a counter-dispute with eBay, writing that I am lying (it’s not clear about what) and that although they asked me for a refund, I sent the package anyway.
I pointed out that their refund request reached me 3 business days after I shipped, and that I couldn’t refund them immediately because then they could have kept both the money and the package. They did not reply to that.
I respond to the dispute with the documentation I have, and the next day the buyer closes the dispute to open one with PayPal asking for the full amount (product + shipping costs).
The package remained stuck at a storage center with the explanation that it was not possible to find the address, but that seems strange to me since eBay itself generated the label!
A little while ago the package came back to me, everything seems fine except for the fact that the original label is no longer there, and the tape I had signed in triplicate is also gone and in its place there is regular tape (so it was definitely opened and resealed).
Now I wanted to try to refund the buyer to close the matter (excluding shipping costs), but when I click to refund them I get an error: "
b) since the transaction has in fact been canceled, after the refund could I have eBay remove the negative feedback?
sika700
MentoreKind regards.
amyamalia88
OPHi Sika, thanks for your reply.
Actually, it doesn’t even let me choose the amount; as soon as I try to click “refund,” it gives me that error message above.
Also, I don’t understand why I should be the one losing money on shipping when the change of mind came from the buyer’s side. The listing clearly specified:
- the shipping cost (it was not free)
- that returns were not accepted.
I can accept the return too, but I paid the shipping costs! If they had told me before shipping (as has already happened once in the past), I would have simply refunded the full amount and that would be it.
sika700
MentoreIf you try to simply refund, it’s normal to get the warning that there is an open dispute.
What kind of dispute did they open for you... item not received or not as described?
The presence of the dispute then obliges you to take action.
So decide what’s best to do to minimize the damage.... keeping in mind that you have the item in your hands... so, in my opinion, it’s better to give a full refund and be done with it...
Kind regards.
amyamalia88
OPItem not received was the first dispute, to which I replied by attaching the shipping label and the next day the buyer himself closed it.
The second was the following: The buyer opened a payment dispute, reason: The buyer has not yet received the item (I also attached a summary of what happened and the shipping label to this one).
I saw that you have tons of feedback, so I wonder: if someone ordered an item from you, you ship it and then they changed their mind, why should you be the one to pay the shipping costs?
From your side, you did exactly what you were supposed to do; in the end, the one who makes the mistake pays.
Then the shipping costs are 5e, it's not about the cost but about the principle.
sika700
MentoreIf they receive the package and then change their mind, they open a return request for second thoughts and send it back at their own expense; I am required to refund them in full.
It’s not an eBay issue, but one of Italian law: "European regulations and the consumer code provide that, in the event of exercising the right of withdrawal, the consumer is entitled to a full refund of all payments made to the seller, namely the purchase costs and any standard delivery costs of the products."
Kind regards.