AI corner of eBay
Summary: The discussion titled "Cantonate dell'AI di ebay" involves multiple participants exchanging brief messages with no apparent content, making it impossible to summarize meaningful interactions or conclusions from the thread.
Yesterday eBay removed a couple of my listings for coins on alleged "counterfeiting" grounds, which I appealed because the accusation had no basis at all.
Both appeals were rejected because "the sale of objects/documents bearing Nazi symbols (e.g. fasces, swastika, eagle, skull, SS, even if concealed), including Iron Crosses and related relics dating back to World War II, is not allowed."
The coins in question are:
2 Deutsche Mark 1990 from West Germany dedicated to Franz Josef Strauß, a German statesman and for a long time CSU chairman and president of Bavaria.
and then hear, hear...
ONE PENNY 1945 & HALF PENNY 1946 of the United Kingdom/United Kingdom of GEORGE VI.
George VI... Nazi...
Serious is the equation Germany=Nazism tout court.
The accusation is ridiculous for two coins from the immediate postwar period issued by the United Kingdom, which fought Nazism with all its might.
As usual, no possibility of further appeal. Final and irrevocable decision.
It would be better if eBay relied on natural deficiency... It would do less damage.
mocer-75
my apologies for the misgender and I'm ready to be sacrificed in Wewelsburg Castle!
cizeta1964
Hi mocer-75... Forgiven, 🥰🥰 you don't need to sacrifice yourself in Wewelsburg Castle, which I don't even know where it is! 😄
vonbalden
Wewelsburg Castle in the Rhineland is an estate that should be visited when the sun goes down and the whistle of the wind makes the collar rise up. It was a top-secret place where Pan-Germanism was celebrated and ancient Germans and the peoples who once descended and settled in the territory were discussed, such as the Goths, Visigoths, Lombards, and the other tribes based in the Oder-Vistula region. It is rumored that Karl der GroBe, aka Charlemagne, king of the Franks, the Lombards, and founder of the Carolingian Empire, still appears in spirit to visitors today. Maybe mocer, he is hiding something from us..
mocer-75
vonbalden you always want to know too much, curiosity kills the cat 😄
mocer-75
Well, well, I bought this on July 2, 2023, so not twenty-thirty, here on eBay the following coin:
2 MARK Marchi Coin Deutsches Reich Germany 1938 reichmark
And I’ll say one more thing: by entering the very simple search key: "2 MARK 1938 reichmark" coins come up with the problematic symbol clearly visible.
I’d like to agree with the good cizeta1964, good that abusive sellers get flagged.
vonbalden
Well.. the good cizeta, mocer. She is a kind maiden, perhaps the last one left among the many users who populated the forum and the lounge in years now long gone. A guy I’d exchanged a few messages with
privately, some time ago asked me: where did all the maidens go? To other platforms, on social media, where? And above all, why? Good question.
cizeta1964
💕💕💕💕💕💕💕❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘
heavenwelkin
Good morning etnacoins
Have you double-checked whether the items you are selling violate eBay rules?
On this occasion I invite you to read about:
Offensive material policy
https://www.ebay.it/help/policies/prohibited-restricted-items/regole-sul-materiale-offensivo?id=4324
Pay ATTENTION, as repeated violations of the rules can lead to suspension of your account, preventing you from continuing to sell on eBay.
Kind regards
etnacoins
OPHello heavenwelkin and thanks for participating.
But maybe I wasn’t clear: do you really think Nazi symbols could ever appear on some George VI coins and on a 1990 German coin?
The problem is that eBay is relying way too much on an AI that doesn’t work and is causing huge damage. To me for sure, by removing around 30 listings (!!) with absurd, nonsensical, and false reasons.
What can I do to defend myself? Nothing.
heavenwelkin
I did a search with the help of artificial intelligence and YES, there are correlations with Nazism as regards both George VI and Franz Josef Strauß.
If names or symbols are scanned through artificial intelligence that has access to the web there’s not much you can do, avoid putting those coins up for sale again.
etnacoins
OPI raise the issue precisely because I think AI is stupid! And you only give me yet another proof!
I think eBay doesn't need your "indulgence" but a wake-up call.
We won't be the ones to give it, but at least let's not state the obvious again.
If then the correlation Strauß=Nazism depends on the statesman's nationality, I think eBay will have a problem with 80 million Germans.
If you then find one between George VI and Hitler... you have a problem too.
Thanks for the valuable advice, but if today AI finds a correlation between George VI and the glorification of Nazism, tomorrow it will find one between the coin (for example) dedicated to Segre and the Holocaust!
heavenwelkin
Franz Josef Strauß (1915-1988)
No direct involvement in the Holocaust, but his role in the reintegration of some former Nazis into German politics has been discussed.
Relations with former Nazis: In the 1950s-60s, some former Nazis were integrated into German institutions, and Strauß was criticized for his attitude toward some of these figures.
Franz Josef Strauß, although he lived through the Third Reich and served in the Wehrmacht, was neither an active Nazi nor involved in the Holocaust, but he was criticized for some postwar political choices.
George VI (1895-1952)
George VI was a symbol of resistance against Hitler and has no connection to Nazism or the Holocaust.
Opposition to Nazism: During World War II, George VI and his family were a symbol of British resistance against Nazi Germany.
Support for Churchill: He supported Winston Churchill and the British effort against Hitler.
Help for Jews: Although British policy on Jewish immigration was controversial (especially because of restrictions in Palestine), George VI is not directly associated with decisions that hindered Jews' escape from Europe.
No link to Nazism or the Holocaust; in fact, George VI was one of the leaders of resistance to Hitler's forces.
This is what ChatGPT artificial intelligence found
Kind regards
etnacoins
OPSo artificial intelligence IS NOT the system that eBay should adopt to check the accuracy of listings and compliance with the rules.
This is my answer.
Thank you and kind regards
sika700
So??
Tell eBay yourself... because I can’t help but laugh! 😂
cizeta1964
Also pay attention to another thing: in your listings you describe yourself as a private seller, but over the past year you have far exceeded the sales "limits" to define yourself as such, based on what is established by DAC07, a regulation at European level.
This has been discussed a lot in the community, ebay also "cuts" listings from sellers who define themselves as private but who, because of their sales volumes and quantities, cannot define themselves that way.
This, of course, is at eBay's discretion, not the community's and not even any "sore losers".
etnacoins
OPThe DAC7 directive requires eBay to share transaction data about its users with tax authorities in certain circumstances.
Copy&paste: "If you are a seller residing in the EU and in a calendar year your sales reach EUR 2,000 or you complete 30 transactions, eBay is required to communicate certain information to the competent tax authorities under the regulations".
The rest are your deductions. Wrong ones.
I went over €2000 because I sold three fairly valuable watches, but that doesn't make me a professional seller, just as it doesn't make someone who sells a used car on eBay for 20,000 a professional seller.
And in fact eBay doesn't claim anything of the sort.
It's simply that eBay's AI is fixating on my account because it's badly programmed. And eBay isn't doing a damn thing.
cizeta1964
The rest are your deductions. Wrong ones.
I’ve gone over €2000 because I sold three watches of decent value, but that doesn’t make me a professional seller, just as it doesn’t make someone who sells a used car on eBay for 20,000 a professional seller.
And eBay doesn’t claim anything like that, in fact
I invite you to read the many discussions on the matter in the community; it’s well known that eBay starts by cutting and closing listings, no one said that was right.
Simply put, eBay’s AI is going after my account because it’s poorly programmed. And eBay doesn’t give a damn.
You’re on the 3rd post on the topic, you must have noticed I imagine that it’s always more or less the same people responding (which doesn’t stop them from doing the same for others too, but evidently no one cares), and none of the answers you’ve received are good enough for you; the question is: why do you keep writing if you already know the answer?
If you think that through the community you can spark a “popular uprising” by other sellers in the same situation as you, you’re badly mistaken; in the community only people with a problem write, usually they’re unhappy with the answers but they’re careful not to give any themselves to others, they take it out on whoever replies and then disappear until the next problem.
etnacoins
OPeBay thanks you.
Have a nice day
cizeta1964
eBay thanks you.
Are you sure? Because users don't do it either; if they don't get the answers they want, they simply take it out on the person who responds. Sure, it's easy, but just as surely not a solution.
sika700
This is the third conversation you've opened for the same reason...
Would you like to let us know what kind of response you'd like?
That way we can give it to you and the next conversation you open... hopefully... will be for another reason...
Have a good evening.
etnacoins
OPAbsolutely not. This Nazi thing is new. Are you obligated to comment on every post?
sika700
I’d say no... but it’s funny...
Good evening.
marioelegio
Unfortunately, eBay's AI is well known for being very unintelligent.