Policy
Summary: The discussion titled "Policy" involved multiple participants who exchanged contributions throughout the session. Though the content of the posts is not provided, interaction among alessfer-1564, cizeta1964, aracnotto, and heavenwelkin suggests a structured dialogue about the topic.
Hello everyone,
I bought a historical item from the seller ---libreria_il_tempo_che_fu--- from Enna
It seemed like a vintage print from the fascist period (I have historiographical interests).
I receive a cutout from a contemporary textbook glued onto cardboard.
I ask for an explanation and receive this response: "You're all the same, you "Nostalgics", to use an euphemism: you don't understand a damn thing!".
I leave a negative review that is deleted by Ebay, I open a dispute in which I am told that everything is regular, the seller makes fun of me, signing off with a "bye bye". Does any of you know if this site's policy allows all this? Thanks
heavenwelkin
The seller you mentioned is a professional seller and allows returns of the item within 14 days of receipt.
I don't think a seller would react like this, making fun of a buyer like that for no reason.
Also, Ebay deleted a feedback you left that probably didn't comply with the site's rules.
Also, Ebay ruled against you during a dispute.
From the way you tell it, it would seem that the seller is the "BAD" one.
But is that really the case?
Best regards
alessfer-1564
OPDear all,
actually, Ebay had ruled in my favor, only to then change its mind without giving me a reason.
The return shipping cost more than the item.
On Amazon or any site, if I leave a review it doesn't get deleted unless I write offensive words.
The seller wrote offensive words to me. If this is all legal, I take note of it and I won't make any more purchases on this site.
Thanks anyway for your insightful replies.
cizeta1964
The return cost more than the item.
Still insisting? If the item doesn’t conform, return shipping costs are the seller’s responsibility, not the buyer’s.
Instead of continuing to write without knowing, read the rules carefully and get reimbursed - if you’re entitled to it - instead of needlessly making a note on the feedback.
Amazon doesn’t work like eBay, and it’s still possible to report the seller’s misconduct on eBay too.
You still haven’t specified what kind of dispute you opened, so I’d say you still have a lot of the rules to read, not just for eBay.
aracnotto
Hi...
what "seemed" to you matters little, what matters is the description and the listing images!
If ebay ruled against you it’s because either you chose the wrong type of dispute or what you bought is what you received!
alessfer-1564
OPThe seller's friend has arrived..
What I call "appearing" is based on good faith, which is the basis of commercial transactions.
How would you have felt if they had sent you a PIECE OF A SCHOOL BOOK (with lines highlighted with a yellow highlighter on the back) pinned to a little cardboard for 15 euros + shipping?
How do you judge vulgar insults when you ask for clarification? All normal? Is it normal to remove negative reviews?
I hope you're not a seller on Ebay either.
Regards
aracnotto
Hi, I'll start from the end:
eBay has a policy (as you say) regarding feedback; if they don't follow the rules, they are removed without explanation (and they don't only take into account insults or blatantly inappropriate remarks, but also much more subtle aspects that can still be potentially more dangerous for the site). Can they make mistakes? Yes! Can anything be done? No! Either you accept it or you say goodbye and go to Amazon!
Anyone who insults, whether they're a seller or a buyer, is rude and should be treated as such! And you can report them...
I've been buying and selling on the site for over 20 years (also with a certain appreciation from the other side), I know how it works both from experience and from having spent a few minutes reading the rules! So I know that eBay, when in doubt, tends to side with the buyer (with a certain imbalance) and if you lost the dispute there aren't many possibilities: either you messed up the procedure, or you messed up the purchase, thinking you were buying one thing instead of another (and common sense has absolutely nothing to do with it: if I sell you fried air at the price of a luxury perfume, you'll get fried air and not a bottle of Chanel No. 5, even if common sense says no one would sell fried air and no one would buy it. And even if the seller put the fried air in the Chanel bottle but clearly says the dispenser contains fried air, you can't expect to receive a fragrance different from the one stated. You need to read listings from top to bottom, look at all the photos and, if you have the slightest doubt, ask. Without a reply or with a reply that doesn't convince you, forget it because the scam is more likely than the great deal).
If, as you say, at first you were found to be right and later wrong, one of the people who judged your case definitely made a mistake... or the seller provided concrete proof of what they did that turned the situation around!
Basically, almost always, if eBay rules against the buyer, it's because the buyer is dead wrong! Otherwise they rush to refund them because a buyer who feels protected when something goes wrong tends to come back... there are way too many sellers, and losing a few along the way isn't really that big of a problem!
cizeta1964
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
cizeta1964
I open a dispute in which I’m told that everything is in order
What kind of dispute did you open?