Report
Good morning, I’m reporting some unpleasant and costly episodes that have happened to me, and not only to me, lately with Ebay. An offer to buy the listing I posted, with photos, a description noting defects and a price below market value, was accepted. The buyer wasn’t satisfied, wants a refund, I agree to do it after the items are returned. I warn the buyer, who doesn’t reply to me, I warn Ebay that the buyer doesn’t reply to me, they tell me they’ll contact them. Long story short, the items aren’t returned to me, Ebay refunds the buyer and asks me for the refund money. I have to give the items away for free. I explain to Ebay that I’ll give the money if the items are returned to me. Another surprise, Ebay passes the case to a debt collection agency that asks me for the money. Two other times, an item I sold with tracked shipping was lost or stolen. The buyer, quite rightly, reports the item as not arrived. Long story short, Ebay refunds the buyer and takes the money from my account. Items given away for free. I list items for sale, stating and specifying costs, only with shipping in Italy and the European Union. An American buys one of my items anyway, I tell Ebay that, as indicated, I only ship to Italy and the EU, and refund the buyer. Long story short, Ebay still takes its commission for the sold item. Don’t tell me to report the facts to Ebay because I did, but they don’t know what to answer or they tell you they’ll make a report but nothing happens. Sellers are more and more unprotected, despite all the commissions they take.
heavenwelkin
That said, the seller who accepts online payments is always in a bad spot if any post-sale problems arise.
But what you describe isn’t correct, because the eBay system allows you to recover the items when a dispute is underway.
When you get a return notice for an item not as described, you have to take action (at your own expense) to make sure the item is returned to you.
If you simply tell the buyer “okay, send it back” and wait for the dispute to close without providing the return label, what happens is that you lose both the item and the money.
If you follow the procedures provided, I’m not saying you’ll be jumping for joy, but at least you’ll limit the damage.
As for the lost/stolen package issue, it’s normal that eBay refunds the buyer in these cases; you should try contacting the shipper and/or broker to see whether any compensation awaits you.
Best regards.
arcobaleno55
OPAs I wrote, I agreed to issue the refund, I spoke on the phone with Ebay operators for information, saying that I would also pay the return shipping costs, they told me to contact the buyer to return the items, informing them that I would also pay the return shipping costs, and they told me that they would also send a message to the buyer. Unfortunately, they are not providing reliable updates. For lost or stolen items, the shipper is not responsible and does not reimburse; at most, they tell you to insure it, but for items 50/60 years old, how can you have a receipt or invoice, which in any case would only be for a few thousand lire and not the value the item has today, of a few hundred euros
vonbalden
As they explained to you, you moved carelessly. Here on the forum this controversial issue of refunds has been dealt with hundreds of times and there is a standard process to follow. But.. in my opinion, there is a huge mistake at the root of it all. And that is the lack of communication with the buyer. Not to go and tell them that you’re waiting for the item to do the return! First, upfront. With a good description of your item you have many arrows in your quiver to know more about the potential customer. A few short questions to gauge whether they’re a fan of items like yours, or any question about the item you’re offering, can be welcome. And your counterpart understands that you’re not only interested when they pay, that after that you go on vacation until the 20th, and other similarly odd niceties. It doesn’t take much to trigger unwanted behavior. Which often are the children of a sterile, impersonal transaction. As for me, I wouldn’t make the purchase offer at all. It’s another way to 'distance yourself'. I accept, and that’s that. I refuse, and.. 'send my regards to the crowd'. It’s already a robotic world in its own right. People (deep down) detest it now. A cordial greeting.
arcobaleno55
OPGood morning, I’ve been on Ebay for more than 20 years. Years ago, a couple of times, it happened to me to return or have an item returned to me. You had to send the item back, show Ebay proof that you had shipped it, and when the item arrived at the seller’s, the refund would be made. It should still be done this way. Also, it happened to me and to people I know that the item was returned not as you had sent it but with defects, even with broken or swapped parts. Unfortunately there are more and more buyers who try to be clever. The seller always loses out.
heavenwelkin
Let me give you some advice....
When the buyer opens a dispute, don’t even bother arguing with them...
In the appropriate section of the dispute, you can attach the return label.
Buy a return label and attach it in the dispute and you’re all set, so you don’t have to do anything else.
If the buyer decides not to return the item or too much time passes, the dispute closes in your favor and then you get the unused return label reimbursed by the shipping service provider / broker.
These are automated / mechanized systems / procedures where there is no room for interpretation or customization at this stage; you have to follow the procedures exactly, no ifs or buts.
Kind regards.
arcobaleno55
OPGood morning, I have been on Ebay for more than 20 years. Years ago, a couple of times, it happened to me to return an item or have an item returned to me. You had to send the item back, prove to Ebay with a receipt that you had shipped it, and when the item arrived at the seller's place, the refund was issued. It should still be done this way. In addition, it happened to me and to people I know that the item was returned to you not as you had sent it but with defects, even with broken or swapped parts. Unfortunately, there are more and more buyers who try to be clever. The seller always loses out.
heavenwelkin
From this sentence it seems that you haven't kept up to date with the latest procedures regarding non-compliant items, but you kept applying the old method that was used some time ago, which from the description you give me seems basically the same, but evidently you misunderstood some step and that's why you had problems.
If eBay says to provide the shipping label, you attach it in the designated space.
Sorry.
arcobaleno55
OPDoes it seem normal to you that Ebay should rely on a debt collection agency? They should have insurance that would cover it if needed, with all the money they make from sellers without doing anything. Then if I, as a private individual, buy something in stores or on sites and for some reason don't want to keep it, I have to return it, otherwise there's no way they’ll give me my money back.
heavenwelkin
The buyer gets the refund because they follow the procedure.
You don't have to write to the buyer saying you want the item back...... they don't reply to you and you let time pass, then the case gets closed and you lose both the item and the money.
I explained to you what you have to do.
Ebay, to refund the buyer, draws from your funds; if you make the account empty, Ebay has to pay these money.
So it is NORMAL that ebay relies on a debt collection agency.
Ebay can't do as you say with insurance, otherwise everyone would be SMART-ALICKS: buyer and seller (who have made an agreement) would create fake sales of expensive items where then the buyer would declare that they had received a different item, a non-conforming one or an empty package, and ebay would refund without touching the seller's funds but through this insurance.
The seller and the buyer, happy and content, would split the money from the fake sale, kindly paid by ebay's insurance.
Kind regards.
sika700
Every now and then you read some “nice” things too... very funny little story about the insurance... if the Tax Agency had one too, Italy would be a better place! 😂😂😂
Kind regards.
sika700
Good afternoon,
you have to look out for yourself and know eBay’s behavior well.
If you knew that by rejecting a return request you would have given the item to the seller for free, would you have acted the same way?
There you go, by reading the rules you would have found out.
So you should have arranged the return at your own expense; if then the buyer didn’t make themselves available or didn’t ship, you would have been in the right.
Also, if you refund a buyer within the technical time frame, you don’t pay any commission, just 35 cents... if instead you involve eBay here too, you’ve really made a mess of it!
Kind regards.
arcobaleno55
OPAs I said in writing, I agreed to issue the refund, I spoke by phone with eBay operators for information, saying that I would also pay the return shipping costs, they told me to contact the buyer for the return of the items, informing him that I would also pay the return shipping costs, and they told me that they would also send a message to the buyer. Unfortunately, they do not provide reliable information. For lost or stolen items, the carrier is not responsible and does not refund; at most, they tell you to insure it, but for items 50/60 years old, how are you supposed to have a receipt or invoice, which would in any case be for a few thousand lire and not the value the item has today, worth a few hundred euros. Refund made immediately after the purchase, eBay only kept 35 cents.
sika700
It’s not enough to agree to issue the refund, you also have to take care of paying for the return shipping, and if you don’t provide a prepaid label or reimburse the buyer in advance for the return, ebay can’t help you in any other way.
Also, if you sold abroad with currency conversion, obviously the amounts and the fees due to the exchange rate are not refunded, which is only natural.
All of this is written in ebay’s rules.
Kind regards.