Negative feedback left for a starred user vanished into thin air.
good evening! I left a negative review for a highly rated user who sold me reproductions passing them off as originals, as soon as I left the feedback he disappeared into thin air, is it possible that Ebay made him disappear? Can they really be fake and delete other people's reviews? How can I bring the scam to light? Thanks to anyone who replies.
anna299
13 comments
anna299
OPGood evening! Thanks, I'll see you tomorrow. Thank you so much, have a nice evening
heavenwelkin
Unfortunately these days feedback, besides not being a solution to problems, is also easily challengeable because of a wide range of regulations under which it can be removed.
Basically, insult to injury.
heavenwelkin
Good evening anna299
Sure, it is possible that ebay made the feedback disappear for a number of reasons such as:
1) You opened a dispute but did not bring it to a conclusion.
2) You wrote feedback with potentially defamatory content and/or not strictly relevant to the item, but instead making judgments about the seller.
3) You made statements by email or requests without activating the correct procedure for the return.
But there could be other reasons.........
If you provide us with further details we can give you more relevant answers.
Kind regards.
anna299
OPThanks! I simply explained what happened by writing that the seller was dishonest in the sale, advertising vintage postcards when they were actually reproductions of vintage postcards. I also wrote that I tried to contact the seller and ask for a refund, and only the first time did he reply, telling me good luck because he hadn’t specified the date of the postcards. Then I contacted him several more times but got no response at all. I then attached the photo of the seller’s reply to the review. That’s all
marioelegio
Writing that a seller was dishonest not only violates eBay's rules, but also constitutes the crime of aggravated defamation. You can't judge a person yourself for what you consider a wrong and post your verdict on a public forum.
eBay protected you by preventing a possible and well-deserved complaint.
hi
mario
anna299
OPYou're kidding, I hope! He writes about a seller who was dishonest, and that's grounds for a complaint? And for him, the fact that he sold me reproductions as vintage postcards is totally normal?
cizeta1964
If he sold you the postcards as vintage, you'd return them at his expense, then write it on the feedback, without accusing him of bad behavior.
anna299
OPHe didn’t want to accept the return; I wrote to him for over a week, and the first time he replied like this: I hadn’t specified the date of the postcards in the listing, so if you want to make a claim, good luck. that was the first and only response.
heavenwelkin
The seller, when faced with a dispute over an item not matching the description, cannot object, according to eBay rules.
Maybe it would have been better to come to the forum during that phase; we would have guided you toward the correct procedure and told you what the seller could or couldn't do.
You would have gotten your money back with much less stress and frustration.
Sorry.
heavenwelkin
Dear anna299
If the seller sold you postcards that didn’t match the description, you simply had to open a dispute for item not as described.
The seller would have had to pay the return shipping costs and you would have received a full refund.
Keeping the reproduced / non-original postcards without opening a complaint and then writing that the seller was dishonest doesn’t seem great to me.
You could have sent the postcards back to him at his expense and got all your money back.
Kind regards.