New and sealed item, but the buyer reports a malfunction
Summary: The discussion revolves around a new, sealed item that an acquirer claims is malfunctioning. Several participants, including performancebadge, mocer-75, heavenwelkin, and marioelegio, are involved in the conversation to understand the situation and address the issue.
I sold a new, sealed memory card; back then I had ordered it with the Sold and Shipped by Amazon option and I never used it. I sold it on eBay with the "No returns accepted" option.
The buyer says the unit worked for a few days; in fact, he also left me positive feedback, but now he says it no longer works. Since this is a computer product, compatibility issues can easily arise, so I wouldn’t rule out the possibility that he can solve the problem.
What do I do now? I told him to write to the manufacturer with the Amazon proof of purchase and, if necessary, proceed with a replacement. Obviously I’m not available to provide return shipping, and I don’t accept the return because I am not a professional seller and the product has lost value (I already sold it for 30% less than what I paid).
How should one behave in these cases?
marioelegio
Anyway, each person is responsible for what they sell, you can’t ask the buyer to deal with whoever supplied you with the card.
So if it’s returned to you, at your expense, then you’ll be the one to complain about its malfunction to Amazon or to others.
hi
mario
performancebadge
OPI do not agree for the following reasons:
1. The buyer purchased from a private seller, agreeing to a basic type of service;
2. They bought with no returns accepted because the product is new and sealed. The same would apply to a used product as long as it did not arrive different from how shown/declared in the listing;
3. For this they saved 30% on a New item that they would otherwise have paid more for. No professional seller can afford this price; in fact, the same product on eBay has much higher prices. So my "penalty" as a private seller has already happened. If I also have to pay the return shipping costs and reimburse the first shipping costs, we are talking about a triple penalty.
So asking for the manufacturer's warranty seems to me really the most honest thing to do to protect both the seller and the buyer. If we then want to give the buyer all the right, it would be better to buy only on Amazon.
cizeta1964
Whether you agree or not, this is eBay's policy (always read it before listing an item for sale): if you don't accept returns at your own expense, eBay will do it for you, but with your money, and without requiring the buyer to return the item.
heavenwelkin
Ebay does not have control over payments
You may be right about everything, I won't argue that, but if the buyer opens a dispute for an item not as described and ebay doesn't refund them, then the buyer opens a PayPal claim or a claim through their credit card issuer from which the payment was made on Visa/Mastercard, and the money goes back to the buyer.
If you refuse to send the return label, you automatically lose the dispute and ebay still refunds the buyer, who also keeps the item.
Better to limit the damage and make arrangements to get back possession of the sold item.
Kind regards.
marioelegio
It’s not even an eBay rule; it’s our civil code that states that if the item purchased does not have the requirements promised by the seller, the buyer has the possibility of being refunded without having to bear any expense.
The civil code applies to all sellers, while consumer law applies only to professional sellers.
For this reason, no seller can refuse a return in the event of non-conformity, and return shipping costs must be borne by the seller. A private seller can only refuse a return due to a change of mind, and is not subject to the legal 24-month warranty.
If you sell the memory card as new and working and then it doesn’t work, the item is clearly not as described.
hi
Mario
heavenwelkin
Ebay provides 30 days of buyer protection, so if the buyer, within 30 days of delivery, reports a problem / defect with their purchase, they can open a dispute on ebay for item not as described.
If the buyer accepts your suggestions and does not open a dispute, the matter ends there.
If the buyer decides to open a dispute, you will have to take care of managing it.
I'll tell you right away that you will have to provide a return label at your own expense and attach it to the dispute, after which the buyer will have a certain number of days to send it back.
Once you have received the item, you will have to issue a refund and/or ebay will do it automatically after a certain number of days.
Best regards.
mocer-75
Not accepting returns doesn’t protect you from buyers who receive an item that doesn’t work\is faulty and was sold as working instead. Besides, since you haven’t even tested it, you can’t know whether it was working in the first place or not. In any case, you’re the one responsible with the buyer; bouncing them to Amazon doesn’t help much. Also, I read from the listing: "The microSD was sent to me by Vantrue as a replacement." as a post, I’d say...
performancebadge
OPI wanted to know: what would the implications be? I mean, he can’t manage to sort it out with the seller — who, in any case, seems very flexible — who would be in the right in this transaction in the event of a dispute?
I don’t even know whether it can be opened given the feedback exchange that has already taken place, because I’ve never had that happen.